Extbase Variable Dump
Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Evaluationprototypepersistent entity (uid=269, pid=630)
   title => protected'The effectiveness of core and earmarked funding in multilateral development 
      cooperation' (87 chars)
   abstract => protected'Amid pressing global challenges, multilateral organisations are delivering a
       substantial and increasing part of official development assistance (ODA). M
      ultilateral organisations receive funding from member states via two differe
      nt financing modalities: core funding and earmarked funding, including trust
       funds. In these times of tightened spending and budgetary cuts, questions r
      egarding the effectiveness of different financing modalities have become hig
      hly relevant. Yet, current research and policy discussions on these question
      s do not provide a clear overall picture, and empirical evidence on differen
      t financing modalities is scattered. Therefore, this systematic review analy
      ses the state of knowledge on the effectiveness of core and earmarked fundin
      g. This entailed a systematic identification of literature that presentsempi
      rical evidence on the effectiveness of different financing modalities. Follo
      wing a strict search process and quality assessment, 36 publications were in
      cluded and analysed. The analysis draws on a nuanced, three-dimensional conc
      
      
      nd “system”). The review demonstrates, among other things, that core fun
      ding appears to be more effective than earmarked funding with regard to outc
      ome effectiveness at the project level. Importantly, the review identifies s
      everal evidence gaps, primarily concerning the system level.' (1504 chars)
   caseUid => protected8020 (integer)
   status => protected'done' (4 chars)
   product => protected'sr' (2 chars)
   participants => protected'' (0 chars)
   email => protected'' (0 chars)
   measure => protected'' (0 chars)
   short => protected'Keine Angabe' (12 chars)
   partnerCountries => protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\ObjectStorageprototypeobject (empty)
   regions => protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\ObjectStorageprototypeobject (empty)
   involvedOrganisations => protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\ObjectStorageprototypeobject (2 items)
      0000000000000bcb0000000000000000 => Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Orgaprototypepersistent entity (uid=293, pid=630)
         title => protected'German Institute for Development Evaluation (DEval)' (51 chars)
         uid => protected293 (integer)
         _localizedUid => protected293 (integer)modified
         _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
         _versionedUid => protected293 (integer)modified
         pid => protected630 (integer)
      0000000000000bd00000000000000000 => Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Orgaprototypepersistent entity (uid=521, pid=630)
         title => protected'Expert Group for Aid Studies (EBA)' (34 chars)
         uid => protected521 (integer)
         _localizedUid => protected521 (integer)modified
         _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
         _versionedUid => protected521 (integer)modified
         pid => protected630 (integer)
   involved => protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\ObjectStorageprototypeobject (2 items)
      0000000000000c120000000000000000 => Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Involvedprototypepersistent entity (uid=11, pid=630)
         title => protected'Political institution' (21 chars)
         uid => protected11 (integer)
         _localizedUid => protected11 (integer)modified
         _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
         _versionedUid => protected11 (integer)modified
         pid => protected630 (integer)
      0000000000000c0d0000000000000000 => Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Involvedprototypepersistent entity (uid=15, pid=630)
         title => protected'Other' (5 chars)
         uid => protected15 (integer)
         _localizedUid => protected15 (integer)modified
         _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
         _versionedUid => protected15 (integer)modified
         pid => protected630 (integer)
   contacts => protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\ObjectStorageprototypeobject (2 items)
      0000000000000c510000000000000000 => Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Contactprototypepersistent entity (uid=415, pid=630)
         name => protected'Judith Ihl' (10 chars)
         mail => protected'judith.ihl@deval.org' (20 chars)
         orga => protectedLf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Orgaprototypepersistent entitysee above (uid=293, pid=630)
         website => protected'https://www.deval.org' (21 chars)
         uid => protected415 (integer)
         _localizedUid => protected415 (integer)modified
         _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
         _versionedUid => protected415 (integer)modified
         pid => protected630 (integer)
      0000000000000c7c0000000000000000 => Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Contactprototypepersistent entity (uid=417, pid=630)
         name => protected'Angela Heucher' (14 chars)
         mail => protected'angela.heucher@deval.org' (24 chars)
         orga => protectedLf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Orgaprototypepersistent entitysee above (uid=293, pid=630)
         website => protected'https://www.deval.org' (21 chars)
         uid => protected417 (integer)
         _localizedUid => protected417 (integer)modified
         _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
         _versionedUid => protected417 (integer)modified
         pid => protected630 (integer)
   sectors => protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\ObjectStorageprototypeobject (1 items)
      0000000000000c920000000000000000 => Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Sectorprototypepersistent entity (uid=26, pid=630)
         name => protected'Unallocated / Unspecified' (25 chars)
         num => protected'crs998' (6 chars)
         uid => protected26 (integer)
         _localizedUid => protected26 (integer)modified
         _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
         _versionedUid => protected26 (integer)modified
         pid => protected630 (integer)
   funders => protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\ObjectStorageprototypeobject (1 items)
      0000000000000cc80000000000000000 => Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Funderprototypepersistent entity (uid=5, pid=630)
         title => protected'Grants from a foundation/EU/DFG/other organisation' (50 chars)
         uid => protected5 (integer)
         _localizedUid => protected5 (integer)modified
         _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
         _versionedUid => protected5 (integer)modified
         pid => protected630 (integer)
   fundingOrgaOpen => protected'DEval' (5 chars)
   fundingOther => protected'' (0 chars)
   beginEndYear => protected'2025' (4 chars)
   sourceOfFunding => protected'' (0 chars)
   fundingBmz => protected'' (0 chars)
   finanzOrga => protected'1' (1 chars)
   fundingOrga => protected'' (0 chars)
   additionalRie => protectedFALSE
   additionalRieNo => protected'' (0 chars)
   crsKeyCount => protected'' (0 chars)
   websiteUrl => protected'' (0 chars)
   website => protectedFALSE
   globalproject => protected'' (0 chars)
   gizInvolved => protectedFALSE
   kfwInvolved => protectedFALSE
   orgDoSonstige => protected'' (0 chars)
   orgNro => protectedFALSE
   orgStiftungPolitisch => protectedFALSE
   orgMultilat => protectedFALSE
   orgPolitik => protectedTRUE
   orgPrivatsektor => protectedFALSE
   orgBildung => protectedFALSE
   orgInteressensver => protectedFALSE
   orgDoInternational => protectedFALSE
   orgPrivatspender => protectedFALSE
   orgSonstiges => protectedTRUE
   orgUnbekannt => protectedFALSE
   orgNroLokal => protectedFALSE
   orgPolitikLokal => protectedFALSE
   orgInteressensverLokal => protectedFALSE
   orgBeratungLokal => protectedFALSE
   orgForschungLokal => protectedFALSE
   orgPrivatsektorLokal => protectedFALSE
   orgBildungLokal => protectedFALSE
   orgaUncodiert => protectedFALSE
   crsWeissnicht => protectedFALSE
   methodeAlt => protected'' (0 chars)
   pdfTitle1 => protected'' (0 chars)
   pdfLink1 => protected'' (0 chars)
   pdfTitle2 => protected'' (0 chars)
   pdfLink2 => protected'' (0 chars)
   websiteTitle1 => protected'The effectiveness of core and earmarked funding in multilateral development 
      cooperation (Discussion Paper)' (106 chars)
   websiteLink1 => protected'https://www.deval.org/fileadmin/Redaktion/PDF/05-Publikationen/Berichte/2025
      _Multilaterale_EZ/DEval-DP-02-2025-MultilateralDC-Web.pdf' (133 chars)
   websiteTitle2 => protected'' (0 chars)
   websiteLink2 => protected'' (0 chars)
   rieMethod => protected'No specification' (16 chars)
   pdfContents => protected' Judith Ihl  Angela Heucher ' (28 chars)
   additionalInfo => publicNULL
   compareHash => protected'e35ef415cdc0312e354be96ebed2b3a2' (32 chars)
   uid => protected269 (integer)
   _localizedUid => protected269 (integer)modified
   _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
   _versionedUid => protected269 (integer)modified
   pid => protected630 (integer)
Extbase Variable Dump
array(5 items)
   settings => array(2 items)
      detailPid => '632' (3 chars)
      listPid => '571' (3 chars)
   evaluation => Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Evaluationprototypepersistent entity (uid=269, pid=630)
      title => protected'The effectiveness of core and earmarked funding in multilateral development 
         cooperation' (87 chars)
      abstract => protected'Amid pressing global challenges, multilateral organisations are delivering a
          substantial and increasing part of official development assistance (ODA). M
         ultilateral organisations receive funding from member states via two differe
         nt financing modalities: core funding and earmarked funding, including trust
          funds. In these times of tightened spending and budgetary cuts, questions r
         egarding the effectiveness of different financing modalities have become hig
         hly relevant. Yet, current research and policy discussions on these question
         s do not provide a clear overall picture, and empirical evidence on differen
         t financing modalities is scattered. Therefore, this systematic review analy
         ses the state of knowledge on the effectiveness of core and earmarked fundin
         g. This entailed a systematic identification of literature that presentsempi
         rical evidence on the effectiveness of different financing modalities. Follo
         wing a strict search process and quality assessment, 36 publications were in
         cluded and analysed. The analysis draws on a nuanced, three-dimensional conc
         
         
         nd “system”). The review demonstrates, among other things, that core fun
         ding appears to be more effective than earmarked funding with regard to outc
         ome effectiveness at the project level. Importantly, the review identifies s
         everal evidence gaps, primarily concerning the system level.' (1504 chars)
      caseUid => protected8020 (integer)
      status => protected'done' (4 chars)
      product => protected'sr' (2 chars)
      participants => protected'' (0 chars)
      email => protected'' (0 chars)
      measure => protected'' (0 chars)
      short => protected'Keine Angabe' (12 chars)
      partnerCountries => protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\ObjectStorageprototypeobject (empty)
      regions => protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\ObjectStorageprototypeobject (empty)
      involvedOrganisations => protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\ObjectStorageprototypeobject (2 items)
         0000000000000bcb0000000000000000 => Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Orgaprototypepersistent entity (uid=293, pid=630)
            title => protected'German Institute for Development Evaluation (DEval)' (51 chars)
            uid => protected293 (integer)
            _localizedUid => protected293 (integer)modified
            _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
            _versionedUid => protected293 (integer)modified
            pid => protected630 (integer)
         0000000000000bd00000000000000000 => Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Orgaprototypepersistent entity (uid=521, pid=630)
            title => protected'Expert Group for Aid Studies (EBA)' (34 chars)
            uid => protected521 (integer)
            _localizedUid => protected521 (integer)modified
            _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
            _versionedUid => protected521 (integer)modified
            pid => protected630 (integer)
      involved => protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\ObjectStorageprototypeobject (2 items)
         0000000000000c120000000000000000 => Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Involvedprototypepersistent entity (uid=11, pid=630)
            title => protected'Political institution' (21 chars)
            uid => protected11 (integer)
            _localizedUid => protected11 (integer)modified
            _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
            _versionedUid => protected11 (integer)modified
            pid => protected630 (integer)
         0000000000000c0d0000000000000000 => Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Involvedprototypepersistent entity (uid=15, pid=630)
            title => protected'Other' (5 chars)
            uid => protected15 (integer)
            _localizedUid => protected15 (integer)modified
            _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
            _versionedUid => protected15 (integer)modified
            pid => protected630 (integer)
      contacts => protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\ObjectStorageprototypeobject (2 items)
         0000000000000c510000000000000000 => Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Contactprototypepersistent entity (uid=415, pid=630)
            name => protected'Judith Ihl' (10 chars)
            mail => protected'judith.ihl@deval.org' (20 chars)
            orga => protectedLf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Orgaprototypepersistent entitysee above (uid=293, pid=630)
            website => protected'https://www.deval.org' (21 chars)
            uid => protected415 (integer)
            _localizedUid => protected415 (integer)modified
            _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
            _versionedUid => protected415 (integer)modified
            pid => protected630 (integer)
         0000000000000c7c0000000000000000 => Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Contactprototypepersistent entity (uid=417, pid=630)
            name => protected'Angela Heucher' (14 chars)
            mail => protected'angela.heucher@deval.org' (24 chars)
            orga => protectedLf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Orgaprototypepersistent entitysee above (uid=293, pid=630)
            website => protected'https://www.deval.org' (21 chars)
            uid => protected417 (integer)
            _localizedUid => protected417 (integer)modified
            _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
            _versionedUid => protected417 (integer)modified
            pid => protected630 (integer)
      sectors => protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\ObjectStorageprototypeobject (1 items)
         0000000000000c920000000000000000 => Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Sectorprototypepersistent entity (uid=26, pid=630)
            name => protected'Unallocated / Unspecified' (25 chars)
            num => protected'crs998' (6 chars)
            uid => protected26 (integer)
            _localizedUid => protected26 (integer)modified
            _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
            _versionedUid => protected26 (integer)modified
            pid => protected630 (integer)
      funders => protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\ObjectStorageprototypeobject (1 items)
         0000000000000cc80000000000000000 => Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Funderprototypepersistent entity (uid=5, pid=630)
            title => protected'Grants from a foundation/EU/DFG/other organisation' (50 chars)
            uid => protected5 (integer)
            _localizedUid => protected5 (integer)modified
            _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
            _versionedUid => protected5 (integer)modified
            pid => protected630 (integer)
      fundingOrgaOpen => protected'DEval' (5 chars)
      fundingOther => protected'' (0 chars)
      beginEndYear => protected'2025' (4 chars)
      sourceOfFunding => protected'' (0 chars)
      fundingBmz => protected'' (0 chars)
      finanzOrga => protected'1' (1 chars)
      fundingOrga => protected'' (0 chars)
      additionalRie => protectedFALSE
      additionalRieNo => protected'' (0 chars)
      crsKeyCount => protected'' (0 chars)
      websiteUrl => protected'' (0 chars)
      website => protectedFALSE
      globalproject => protected'' (0 chars)
      gizInvolved => protectedFALSE
      kfwInvolved => protectedFALSE
      orgDoSonstige => protected'' (0 chars)
      orgNro => protectedFALSE
      orgStiftungPolitisch => protectedFALSE
      orgMultilat => protectedFALSE
      orgPolitik => protectedTRUE
      orgPrivatsektor => protectedFALSE
      orgBildung => protectedFALSE
      orgInteressensver => protectedFALSE
      orgDoInternational => protectedFALSE
      orgPrivatspender => protectedFALSE
      orgSonstiges => protectedTRUE
      orgUnbekannt => protectedFALSE
      orgNroLokal => protectedFALSE
      orgPolitikLokal => protectedFALSE
      orgInteressensverLokal => protectedFALSE
      orgBeratungLokal => protectedFALSE
      orgForschungLokal => protectedFALSE
      orgPrivatsektorLokal => protectedFALSE
      orgBildungLokal => protectedFALSE
      orgaUncodiert => protectedFALSE
      crsWeissnicht => protectedFALSE
      methodeAlt => protected'' (0 chars)
      pdfTitle1 => protected'' (0 chars)
      pdfLink1 => protected'' (0 chars)
      pdfTitle2 => protected'' (0 chars)
      pdfLink2 => protected'' (0 chars)
      websiteTitle1 => protected'The effectiveness of core and earmarked funding in multilateral development 
         cooperation (Discussion Paper)' (106 chars)
      websiteLink1 => protected'https://www.deval.org/fileadmin/Redaktion/PDF/05-Publikationen/Berichte/2025
         _Multilaterale_EZ/DEval-DP-02-2025-MultilateralDC-Web.pdf' (133 chars)
      websiteTitle2 => protected'' (0 chars)
      websiteLink2 => protected'' (0 chars)
      rieMethod => protected'No specification' (16 chars)
      pdfContents => protected' Judith Ihl  Angela Heucher ' (28 chars)
      additionalInfo => publicNULL
      compareHash => protected'e35ef415cdc0312e354be96ebed2b3a2' (32 chars)
      uid => protected269 (integer)
      _localizedUid => protected269 (integer)modified
      _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
      _versionedUid => protected269 (integer)modified
      pid => protected630 (integer)
   additionalInfo => TRUE
   productType => 'tx_lfrierepo_domain_model_evaluation.facet.sr' (45 chars)
   statusKey => 'tx_lfrierepo_domain_model_evaluation.status.done' (48 chars)
Extbase Variable Dump
Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Orgaprototypepersistent entity (uid=293, pid=630)
   title => protected'German Institute for Development Evaluation (DEval)' (51 chars)
   uid => protected293 (integer)
   _localizedUid => protected293 (integer)modified
   _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
   _versionedUid => protected293 (integer)modified
   pid => protected630 (integer)
Extbase Variable Dump
Lf\LfRierepo\Domain\Model\Orgaprototypepersistent entity (uid=293, pid=630)
   title => protected'German Institute for Development Evaluation (DEval)' (51 chars)
   uid => protected293 (integer)
   _localizedUid => protected293 (integer)modified
   _languageUid => protected0 (integer)modified
   _versionedUid => protected293 (integer)modified
   pid => protected630 (integer)
The effectiveness of core and earmarked funding in multilateral development cooperation | Rigorous Impact Evaluation - DEval.org
Systematic Review (SR) Completed

The effectiveness of core and earmarked funding in multilateral development cooperation

Sector (OECD DAC Codes)
Unallocated / Unspecified
Involved Organisations
German Institute for Development Evaluation (DEval)
Expert Group for Aid Studies (EBA)
Funding
DEval
Year (Time of completion)
2025

Further Information

Contact

To Top